The EU Publishes a Report on Credit Rating Practices in the CLO Market


Today’s post is just a very short alert on the publication of a report today by the EU. The report, entitled ‘Thematic Report: EU CLO credit ratings – an overview of Credit Rating Agencies practices and challenges’ is available here. The aim of the report is to examine the rating practices that underlay the development of collateralised loan obligations, with a particular focus on how risk is identified and transmitted within the process. There is also a distinct focus on the stress-testing that the agencies undertake for these products, with ESMA stating in their press release that they ‘expect CRAs to continue to perform regular stress-testing simulations and to provide market participants with granular information on the sensitivity of CLO credit ratings to key economic variables affected by the pandemic’. Steven Maijoor, the Chair of the Regulator, went further and stated that the regulator’s assessments of the agencies’ practices in this particular sector ‘highlight a number of supervisory concerns and risks associated with risking this asset class’. These supervisory concerns include:

·       The internal organisation of CRAs – specifically regarding sharing information between groups of analysts so that a holistic picture of CLO creditworthiness is reached;

·       The interactions with CLO issuers – issuers can identify which agency provides for the best ratings for a particular tranche, so ‘shopping’ and commercial conflicts are a worry for regulators;

·       Model/third party dependencies leading to potential operational risks – there is a dependency on data provided by third parties, which needs to be thoroughly accounted for;

·       Rating methodologies, modelling risks and commercial influence – because CLO models and methodologies are underpinned by assumptions, regulators want CRAs to be clear on the limitations of their methodologies;

·       The thorough analysis of CLOs – regulators want the CRAs to carefully monitor market trends and perform thorough analyses of the CLOs they rate.

Despite the conflicting messages within the final two issues – ESMA acknowledge that the CLO methodologies are underpinned by assumption, but simultaneously request that CLOs are thoroughly analysed – the majority of the issues raised by ESMA are issues that are consistently raised. The need for the protection of analyst independence, a reduction in commercial conflicts of interest, and a holistic process to examining creditworthiness are all common calls in this sector. What it does tell us is that the EU is attempting to be proactive regarding credit rating regulation in this current climate, perhaps on the back of developments including the ECB dismissing traditional rating cut-off points, and prominent politicians calling for more reform in the wake of the pandemic-induced downgrades. How the EU continues to respond will be interesting.

Keywords – EU, Rating agencies, @finregmatters

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Lloyds Bank and the PPI Scandal: The Premature ‘Out of the Woods’ Rhetoric

Image
Today’s very short post focuses upon the news that the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has recently extended the deadline to claim compensation for mis-sold ‘Payment Protection Insurance’ (PPI). Whilst a lot of financial institutions will have to prepare to offset the extended deadline, it is Lloyds that has grabbed the business headlines by apportioning an extra £350 million to offset any further claims that may be made of it – however, this comes only a week or two after the Bank posted its best performance figures in over a decade, as was previously discussed in Financial Regulation Matters . This post will therefore argue that the rhetoric being advanced recently regarding Lloyds – rhetoric like Lloyds represents ‘ a modern day success story ’ is wide of the mark and creates a false sense of security that we simply cannot afford to believe in. The ‘ robust recovery ’ was heralded far and wide upon the publication of Lloyds Bank’s financial performance for the previous fi
Read more

The Analytical Credit Rating Agency: A New Entrant That Will Further Enhance Russia’s Isolation

Image
This short post is based upon a forthcoming article by this author that examines the viability of the latest entrant into the credit rating arena, the Analytical Credit Rating Agency (ACRA). The article, which is due to be published in the European Company Law Journal (and is available here in a pre-published version), looks at the chances of the ACRA succeeding when viewed within the parameters of perception , an aspect that underpins the credit rating sector. For this post, the focus will be upon introducing the ACRA, and then on examining the effect it may have upon the wider political issues affecting the Russian Federation. The Analytical Credit Rating Agency was established in November 2015 and comprises of 27 major Russian companies and financial institutions that serve as its shareholders. The agency, which became the first rating agency to receive accreditation from the Russian Central Bank under the new N 222-FZ Law which was designed to protect investors, has a re
Read more

The Case of Purdue Pharma, the Sackler Family, and the Opioid Crisis

Image
In the first of two short posts today, we will look at the case of the billionaire Sackler Family and their remarkable effect upon American society. The family, who own Purdue Pharma amongst a list of other ventures, have this week seen a massive legal action taken against them by the State of New York who argue that the company is ‘ responsible for the opioid epidemic ’ sweeping through the United States. The attorney-general for New York has called the lawsuit the ‘ nation’s most extensive ’ with respect to the pharmaceutical industry and comes right on the heels of a $270 million suit that was settled in the State of Oklahoma on exactly the same grounds. Whilst the company and the billionaire family who own it did not admit guilt (settling parties rarely do, hence why they settle outside of court) it has potentially opened the trapdoors for litigation. It comes as no surprise then that the company is reportedly considering bankruptcy proceedings in the face of such an onsl
Read more